| Platinum | 1889 Studios | Auctions & Realty |
| Gold | Made You Look Thrift Store |
| Silver | Cornerstone Thrift Store |
| Bronze | Stone's Furniture |
| Top Pick | Goodwill Stores |
| Top Pick | Pearson Block Hous |
| Top Pick | RetroReimagined |
| Top Pick | Rise |
| Top Pick | Vinyl Pro of the Black Hills |