| Platinum | Meadow Ridge Pet Lodge |
| Gold | Stars Rescue |
| Silver | Opp - Ogala Pet Project |
| Bronze | A Place For Meow Rescue |
| Top Pick | Battle Mountain Humane Society |
| Top Pick | Border Paws Rescue |
| Top Pick | Healthy Paws |
| Top Pick | Humane Society-Black Hills |
| Top Pick | Pet Pantry |
| Top Pick | Petco |