| Platinum | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Platinum | Sabatino's Italian Ristorante |
| Gold | Boss' Pizza & Chicken |
| Silver | Piesano's Pacchia |
| Bronze | Lintz Brothers Pizza |
| Top Pick | Blaze Pizza |
| Top Pick | Colonial House Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Marco's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pauly's Pizzeria & Sub Co. |
| Top Pick | Pizza Ranch |