| Platinum | Eileen's Colossal Cookies |
| Platinum | SME's Treats |
| Gold | Mary's Mountain Cookies |
| Silver | Crumbl Cookie |
| Bronze | Bakes Two to Tango |
| Top Pick | Glazed and Dazed Donuts |
| Top Pick | Nell's Gourmet To Go |
| Top Pick | Sunny Lemons Cookies |
| Top Pick | The Cookie Shop |
| Top Pick | The Rustic Nook |