| Platinum | Angel's Catering |
| Gold | Catered by Karen A |
| Gold | The Good Stuffed |
| Silver | Jimmy John's |
| Bronze | Rapid City Elks Lodge #1187 |
| Top Pick | Anthing's Possible Catering |
| Top Pick | Dakota Butcher |
| Top Pick | Eddie's Taco's RC |
| Top Pick | Old School Sliders |
| Top Pick | The Beanery |