| Platinum | Sweetgrass Inn |
| Gold | Bavarian Inn |
| Silver | Econo Lodge |
| Bronze | Courtyard by Marriott |
| Bronze | JC Stage Stop |
| Top Pick | Edelweiss Mountain Lodging |
| Top Pick | Holiday Inn Express and Suites Deadwood |
| Top Pick | Hotel Alex Johnson Rapid City, Curio Collection by Hilton |
| Top Pick | Summer Creek Inn |
| Top Pick | The Rushmore Hotel & Suites, Bw Premier Collection |