| Platinum | Mercys Tacos |
| Gold | Mexico Tipico |
| Silver | Albertanos |
| Bronze | El Sombrero Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Borrachos |
| Top Pick | Borrachos Mexican Diner |
| Top Pick | El Nevado |
| Top Pick | Michelle's Tacos |
| Top Pick | Puerto Vallarta Mexican Restaurant & Tequila Bar |
| Top Pick | Sabor A Mexico |