| Platinum | Armadillos Ice Cream Shop |
| Gold | The Silver Lining Creamery |
| Silver | Cold Stone Creamery |
| Bronze | Dairy Queen |
| Top Pick | A&W All-American Food |
| Top Pick | Chill Your Roll |
| Top Pick | Culver's |
| Top Pick | Leone's Creamery Spearfish |
| Top Pick | Orange Julius |
| Top Pick | The Meltdown Rolled Ice Cream |