| Platinum | Jerry's Cakes & Donuts |
| Gold | Mary's Mountain Cookies |
| Silver | Daylight Donuts |
| Bronze | Eileen's Colossal Cookies |
| Top Pick | Black Hills Bagels |
| Top Pick | Black Hills Bistro |
| Top Pick | Fork Real |
| Top Pick | Pistachio Pie |
| Top Pick | The Silver Lining Creamery |
| Top Pick | The Sour: A Bakery |