| Platinum | Colonial House Restaurant |
| Gold | Millstone Family Restaurant |
| Silver | Cambell Street Cafe |
| Silver | Harriet & Oak |
| Bronze | Tally's Silver Spoon |
| Bronze | The Mud Hole of the Black Hills |
| Top Pick | Black Hills Bagels |
| Top Pick | Fairmont Diner |
| Top Pick | Robbinsdale Lanes |
| Top Pick | Ron's Cafe |