| Platinum | Cory's Point S Tire and Auto Service |
| Gold | Super Lube |
| Silver | Elite Auto Repair |
| Bronze | Tires Tires Tires Auto Service & Tire Center |
| Top Pick | Anytime Auto Sales |
| Top Pick | Great Western Tire Spearfish |
| Top Pick | Hills Tire & Supply |
| Top Pick | Liberty Superstores |
| Top Pick | Mark's Auto Repair |
| Top Pick | Tires Plus |